E254: Unlock the Secrets Behind Business Valuations: What Every Owner Needs to Know Before Selling - Watch Here

About the Guest(s):

Gregory Caruso is a seasoned business valuator with over 40 years of experience. Holding both a JD and CPA, Gregory is licensed in the state of Maryland. His extensive background includes 10 years in a family home building operation and significant experience in business brokerage and valuation. Author of "The Art of Business Valuation," Gregory has contributed to continued education through his role as editor in chief and host of a monthly webinar for the National Association of Certified Valuators and Analysts (NACVA). His expertise spans a wide array of valuation contexts, including ESOPs, estate planning, and exit strategies for small to medium-sized businesses.

Episode Summary:

In this episode of the How2Exit podcast, host Ronald Skelton speaks with Gregory Caruso, an expert in business valuation, to unravel the complexities of how companies are valued. Gregory's vast experience is laid bare as he shares the differences in valuation methodologies, adapting from roles in home building business operations to being a leading business valuator. His insights into the industry's standards offer a unique perspective, particularly with the challenges surrounding price versus value concepts.

As the episode unfolds, Gregory delves into the myriad valuation models, addressing common misconceptions and explaining the evolution within the field. He discusses how valuations vary based on different purposes—be it for ESOPs, estate planning, or other contexts—and highlights the regulatory requirements attached to each. From exploring the implications of profitability, risk, and management structure on valuations to detailing the intrinsic value assessment versus synergistic worth, Gregory Caruso provides listeners with a robust understanding of the complex valuation landscape that affects business owners considering an exit strategy.

Key Takeaways:

• Understanding Valuation Models: Business valuations typically involve a handful of established models, although variations exist to suit specific purposes like ESOP or SBA requirements.
• Importance of Management and Profitability: Enhancing profitability and preparing the management team can significantly impact a business's valuation.
• Role of Judgment in Valuation: Beyond mathematical calculations, Timothy emphasizes the role of professional judgment in assessing business value.
• Impact of Purpose on Valuation: The intended use of a valuation—whether for market sale, ESOP, or estate planning—alters the methodology and considerations.
• Strategic Insights into ESOPs: ESOPs are valued at fair market value without synergies, making them ideal for industries with lower synergy potentials.

Notable Quotes:

• "Business valuation is future cash flow and the risk of making it." – Gregory Caruso
• "The net result of a valuation is not necessarily a mathematical process. It's judgment." – Gregory Caruso
• "Price is a response to the market… value is what it kind of should be." – Gregory Caruso
• "Fair market value says we can't take synergies into account." – Gregory Caruso
• "Increasing profitability reduces your risk and increases your cash flow." – Gregory Caruso

Article:

Unlocking Business Valuation: Insights from Experts Ronald Skelton and Gregory Caruso

Key Takeaways:

• Business valuation is a realm where price and value often diverge, especially when factoring in unique buyer perspectives and market conditions.
• A deep understanding of profitability and management dynamics can elevate a business’s market readiness and valuation potential.
• ESOPs have intricate valuation methodologies, and understanding these can lead to optimized business strategies and clearer valuation outcomes.

Understanding the Complex World of Business Valuation

In today's fast-paced business environment, valuing a company isn't just about numbers; it's about understanding the nuances between price and value. "Price and value can be two different concepts," says Gregory Caruso, a seasoned business valuator with over 40 years of experience. In a conversation with Ronald Skelton, Caruso delves into the intricacies of business valuation models and explains how various factors, from market dynamics to personal biases, can sway assessments.

The Nuanced Relationship Between Price and Value

Business valuation often reveals a fascinating dichotomy between what a company is worth and what it can sell for. This distinction takes center stage in any serious discussion about valuation techniques. As Caruso points out, "no matter how good you think you are at valuing things, price and value can be two different concepts."

The discussion highlights that price is influenced by numerous intangibles like buyer emotions and market volatility. Factors such as investment trends and industry-specific dynamics can result in prices that do not necessarily align with valuations grounded strictly in financial fundamentals. This underscores the point, "price is what actually happened."

For instance, market exuberance around technological advancements in SaaS companies can inflate perceived worth, sometimes resulting in "offers…that are above synergistic levels." It is paramount for business owners to recognize when market conditions offer unusually high prices and consider the timing of their sale, especially if they receive lucrative, unexpected offers.

The Importance of Profitability and Management in Valuation

One foundational pillar for optimizing a business’s market value is its profitability. Caruso stresses that "profitability is low-hanging fruit." Improving profitability enhances future cash flow and reduces perceived risk, leading to a win-win in valuation terms. He explains that "the more profitable you are, the more risk is reduced," raising the appeal of the business to potential buyers.

Another critical element discussed is the management team's role, particularly when business owners near retirement. A common scenario is the stagnation that occurs when "the owner is 65 and…got three or four key people," often of similar age, lacking successors. As Caruso notes, this can be "a huge impediment to value." Inconsistencies in leadership structures can deter buyers and depress valuation, implicating the importance of grooming successors who can sustain business performance post-exit.

ESOPs and Their Detailed Valuation Framework

Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs) introduce another layer of complexity in business valuations, necessitating a detailed understanding. The discussion reveals that ESOP valuations are obliged to be conducted using fair market value, explicitly excluding synergistic benefits, since "management doesn't have synergies."

Caruso elaborates on how this prohibition affects valuations, emphasizing the need for careful execution and understanding of ESOP-specific regulations. The models used for ESOP valuations often rely on forecasts integrating historical performance. A "discounted cash flow method" is employed, involving projected cash flow against projected risk, an approach that depends heavily on the credibility of "a five-year forecast." This ensures that the estimation of business worth remains grounded in realistic expectations while meeting regulatory criteria.

Summarizing the Key Insights

Throughout the conversation, several recurring insights challenge standard business valuation practices and mindsets. Whether pondering the divergence between market price and intrinsic value, examining the critical factors that enhance valuation such as profitability and adept management, or navigating the specialized world of ESOPs, each theme adds complexity and depth to the business valuation process.

Business owners and stakeholders can gain significantly from understanding these multifaceted processes. By tailoring their strategies and ensuring alignment between operational excellence and market expectations, business leaders can better prepare their enterprises for favorable valuations, whether in traditional sales or more complex ESOP scenarios. As Caruso wisely observes, navigating these waters demands both technical understanding and practical foresight, creating paths to enhanced business exit outcomes.

---- MORE COOL STUFF ---

Are you ready to take your podcast listening to the next level? Subscribe to "DEEPER by How2Exit" newsletter and never miss out on our latest episodes. Join our  newsletter  HERE

Want to stay in touch with what's happening in the Main Street M&A Space?  Subscribe to Growth & Acquisitions(Formerly The Hub)